"The Big Boss" Shot Analysis




PART ONE: Screen-cap analysis based on Sikov’s example:

A man stands right of center in the frame. His face is turned toward the camera, but his body is turned at an angle so that his chest is turned to the right, the top of his left shoulder shown clearly in the shot. The man is only visible from the shoulder up, and only the very top of his head is cut off at the top of the frame. The man wears a white shirt. His eyes are focused on some distant point to the left of the frame, his mouth slightly parted. A light appears to be shining down from the top left corner of the frame, as the light illuminates the majority of the left side of the man’s face and hair. This light source could be the sun or an artificial light source. The right side of the man’s face is a bit more cast in shadow, though not completely as to make his expression unreadable, and a faint shadow casts down from his neck. The underneaths of the man's eyes are somewhat cast in shadow, as well as his eyebrows. The background of the screen-cap is mostly of a black background, possibly suggesting depth or a dark-colored building. One other person stands fully visible at the back of the frame to the right-hand side, visible from the upper-arms upward. One-half of another person stands at the edge of the frame to the right, and only one-half of their face is visible. Both of these figures are blurred out; they wear dark-gray colored shirts. Their faces and expressions are unreadable; their necks are cast in shadow.

PART TWO: Contextualizing the screen-cap in the context of the film:

In this screen-cap, I believe Chao-an is in the midst of fighting one of Hsiao Mi’s men that were sent to fight the workers who were refusing to work. The men were refusing to work at the ice factory because they wanted to know what happened to Hsu Chien and the other workers that went missing, and wound not work until they were either given an answer to their whereabouts or were released from the boss. In this frame, Chao-an’s necklace is not visible. This makes me believe that his mother’s pendant was already pulled off from his neck. This means that Chao-an was not afraid to fight anymore. The anger of getting the pendant pulled off of his neck is written across his face here. The two people that stand at the back of the frame are most likely workers at the ice factory, though I am not sure if they were ever named. They stand behind Chao-an, as if they are aware of Chao-an's fighting skills and are waiting for him to get revenge for having his pendant torn off.

Comments

  1. Howdy, Maddy. You did a pretty airtight job at sticking to Sikov's model in your shot analysis, so it was kinda tricky to find fault. You got everything from the slight part in the mouth to the color of the shirts of the men in the background. You did a great job at painting a picture of Lee's face in this shot and I liked the description of the lighting and shading in this shot because I feel like I always fail to remember to mention those elements. Your lucid explanation will probably help me consider those in the future. As for any constructive criticism, I was struggling to find much fault, so what I have is just nitpicks. For example, you could include detail about the shape and size of the frame (i.e. aspect ratio) and also the angle at which it's shot. I feel like the eye level shot really helps convey the resolve in his expression as he prepares to fight more of the men. Other than that, great job!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Leo, thanks so much for the feedback! I completely agree that I should have included detail about the frame and the angle; these all play into the screen-cap in their own ways, and definitely should have been something I touched on in my analysis. Mentioning the aspect ratio could have definitely been beneficial. Also, I agree about what you said about how the eye level shot helps convey his expression; this is definitely an interesting thing and I’m glad you pointed it out! Everything you commented on is helpful. Thanks again!

      -Maddy

      Delete
    2. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
  2. Hi Maddy, sorry im posting this comment so late, i apologize for that.
    I really love the description you gave of Chao-an's face, and personally i did not notice the lighting in the shot being from the top left, so good pickup there. Great description of the men in the background, although i would've liked you to maybe talk about their potential purpose in the shot. Like Leo, the only criticism i have is a nitpick: I don't think that we can assume the workers KNEW what happened to Hsu Chien, but in the context of the story it does not matter since they want their friend back regardless. Great job!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Leo,

      Thank you for your feedback! I understand your point about talking more about how I should have talked more about the two figures in the background and their potential purpose; I could have included a bit more of this in my second paragraph. Also, as for your one criticism, I do say that the workers don’t know what happened to Hsu Chien, but I also say that they want him to be released. In hindsight, I should have left out the latter part! Thanks for pointing it out!

      Thanks,
      Maddy

      Delete

Post a Comment